strategic decision making case study

SUGGESTED TOPICS
The Magazine
Newsletters
Managing Yourself
Managing Teams
Work-life Balance
The Big Idea
Data & Visuals
Case Selections
HBR Learning
Topic Feeds
Account Settings
Email Preferences

Decision making and problem solving

Change management
Competitive strategy
Corporate strategy
Customer strategy

Using ChatGPT to Make Better Decisions

Viktor Mayer-Schönberger
August 24, 2023

Founders, Apply the Scientific Method to Your Startup

Chiara Spina
Arnaldo Camuffo
Alfonso Gambardella
November 18, 2020

What to Do If You Feel Like You've Lost Your Intuition

Dorie Clark
October 19, 2023

A Method for Better Marketing Decisions

Gardiner Morse
July 07, 2014

The Power of Real-Time Advertising

B. Bonin Bough
February 05, 2013

Why Being Unpredictable Is a Bad Strategy

Mark Chussil
January 05, 2017

How Anxiety Affects CEO Decision Making

Mike Mannor
Viva Ona Bartkus
Luis R Gomez Mejia
July 19, 2016

How to Safeguard Against Cyberattacks on Utilities

Stuart Madnick
January 23, 2020

How to Break Down Work into Tasks That Can Be Automated

Ravin Jesuthasan
John Boudreau
February 20, 2019

A Methodology for Leading Into the Unknown

John Baldoni
July 21, 2008

One-Page Memos, Without Reductionism

April 06, 2010

Executive Physicals: What's the ROI?

Anthony L. Komaroff M.D.
From the September 2009 Issue

Leading in Times of Trauma

Monica C. Worline
Jacoba M. Lilius
Jason M. Kanov
From the January 2002 Issue

How to Tell If You Should Trust Your Statistical Models

Theodoros Evgeniou
Theos Evgeniou
September 22, 2014

5 Strategy Questions Every Leader Should Make Time For

Freek Vermeulen
September 03, 2015

Market Meltdown–How to Stay Strong in Scary Times

Bill Taylor
January 22, 2008

Centralized Decision Making Helps Kill Bad Products

John Joseph
Ronald Klingebiel
October 18, 2016

Is it Time for Mutiny?

Patrick J. Murphy
April 09, 2013

A 4-Step Process to Help Senior Teams Prioritize Decisions

Peter Hopper
Jugnu Sakuja
March 27, 2017

When It Comes to Data, Skepticism Matters

Thomas C. Redman
October 22, 2014

Don’t Overlook This Critical Skill When Interviewing Executives

Aaron Mitchell Finegold
Umesh Ramakrishnan
November 07, 2024

Scaling Up Transformational Innovations

Ananya Sheth
Mike DiPaola
Linda A. Hill
From the November–December 2024 Issue

A Strategic Approach for Meeting Customer Demand as Quickly as Possible

Kaihan Krippendorff
Robert C. Wolcott
October 23, 2024

How to Learn from Your Mistakes and Make Better Decisions

Cheryl Strauss Einhorn
September 25, 2024

Digital Twins Can Help You Make Better Strategic Decisions

Graham Kenny
Ganna Pogrebna
September 23, 2024

Why Leadership Teams Fail

Thomas Keil
Marianna Zangrillo
From the September–October 2024 Issue

Where Data-Driven Decision-Making Can Go Wrong

Michael Luca
Amy C. Edmondson

Build Better Teams

Angus Dawson
Katy George
Gregory LeStage
Sara Nilsson DeHanas
Pete Gerend
Nitin Nohria
September 01, 2024

Build a Corporate Culture That Works

From the July–August 2024 Issue

How to Vet Information Before Making a Decision

Alex Edmans
June 20, 2024

Use Active Listening to Help a Colleague Make a Hard Decision

May 15, 2024

The Art of Asking Smarter Questions

Arnaud Chevallier
Frédéric Dalsace
Jean-Louis Barsoux
From the May–June 2024 Issue

Make Decisions with a VC Mindset

Ilya A. Strebulaev

Don’t Let Gen AI Limit Your Team’s Creativity

From the March–April 2024 Issue

How Fast Should Your Company Really Grow?

Gary P. Pisano

How Machine Learning Will Transform Supply Chain Management

Morris A. Cohen
Rohan Deshpande
Vinayak Deshpande

Why Consistent Growth Is So Challenging

Paul Leinwand
Dunigan O'Keeffe
Karen Harris
Austin Kimson
March 01, 2024

How to Make Peace with a Company Decision You Don’t Like

February 19, 2024

Getting Board Members on Board: The Role of the CIO in AI Strategy

February 14, 2024

How to Develop Good Judgment as a New Manager

January 29, 2024

Hawaii Best, Inc. (A)

Steven C. Brandt
September 27, 2002

Mount Everest--1996

Michael A. Roberto
Gina M. Carioggia
November 12, 2002

WaveRider Communications, Inc.: The Wireless Last Mile

Scott Schneberger
February 07, 2001

Restructuring JAL

Malcolm P. Baker
Adi Sunderam
Akiko Kanno
November 14, 2013

Organizational Alignment: The 7-S Model

Jeffrey L. Bradach
November 12, 1996

Real-Time Leadership: Find Your Winning Moves When the Stakes Are High

David Noble
Carol Kauffman
February 21, 2023

Quaker Steel and Alloy Corp., Action Plan

John J. Gabarro
August 01, 1980

Arsenic in Drinking Water

Merylin Averill
Jose Gomez-Ibanez
January 22, 2003

Measuring Mutual Fund Performance

Andre F. Perold
Markus F. Mullarkey
May 25, 1998

Urban Homesteading Assistance Board

Chris Berdik
Christine W. Letts
October 01, 2003

Power and Prediction: The Disruptive Economics of Artificial Intelligence

Ajay Agrawal
Joshua Gans
Avi Goldfarb
November 15, 2022

Odyssey Healthcare

Robert F. Higgins
Virginia A. Fuller
Umer Raffat
September 18, 2008

HBR's 10 Must Reads for Executive Teams (with bonus article "Leadership That Gets Results" By Daniel Goleman)

Harvard Business Review
Daniel Goleman
John P. Kotter
Marcus Buckingham
Rita Gunther McGrath
June 27, 2023

Open Talent: Leveraging the Global Workforce to Solve Your Biggest Challenges

John Winsor
Jin Hyun Paik
January 16, 2024

HBR Guide to Designing Your Retirement Toolkit

October 02, 2024

Project Ghost Busters (D)

Kazuhiro Mishina
February 25, 1994

Managing Teams in the Hybrid Age: The HBR Guides Collection (8 Books)

June 13, 2023

Change Leadership: The Kotter Collection (5 Ebooks)

Dan S. Cohen
August 12, 2014

The Auction for Travelport (B)

Andrei Hagiu
Misha R. Sanwal
April 01, 2010

The Age of Outrage: How to Lead in a Polarized World

Karthik Ramanna
October 29, 2024

3 Ways to Build Critical-Thinking Skills

August 16, 2023

Effective Decision-Making: A Case Study

Effective decision-making:, leading an organization through timely and impactful action.

Senior leaders at a top New England insurance provider need to develop the skills and behaviors for better, faster decision-making. This virtually delivered program spans four half-day sessions and includes individual assignments, facilitator-led presentations, and simulation decision-making. Over the past two months, this program touched over 100 leaders, providing them with actionable models and frameworks to use back on the job.

For one of New England’s most iconic insurers, senior leaders are challenged to make timely, effective decisions. These leaders face decisions on three levels: ones they translate to their teams, ones they make themselves, and ones they influence. But in a quickly changing, highly regulated market, risk aversion can lead to slow and ineffective decisions. How can senior leaders practice in a safe environment the quick, yet informed, decision-making necessary for the job while simultaneously learning new models and techniques — and without the learning experience burdening their precious time?

The Effective Decision-Making program was artfully designed to immerse senior leaders in 16 hours of hands-on experience, including reflection and feedback activities, applicable exercises, supporting content, and participation in a business simulation to practice the core content of the program. Participants work together in small groups to complete these activities within a limited time frame, replicating the work environment in which these leaders must succeed. Continuous reflection and group discussion around results create real-time learning for leaders. Application exercises then facilitate the simulation experience and their work back on the job. The program employs a variety of learning methodologies, including:

Individual assignments that incorporate content and frameworks designed to develop effective decision-making skills.
Guided reflection activities to encourage self-awareness and commitments for action.
Large group conversations — live discussions focused on peer input around key learning points.
Small group activities, including virtual role plays designed to build critical interpersonal and leadership skills.
A dynamic business simulation in which participants are charged with translating, making, and influencing difficult decisions.
Facilitator-led discussions and presentations.

Learning Objectives

Participants develop and improve skills to:

Cultivate a leadership mindset that empowers, inspires, and challenges others.
Translate decisions for stronger team alignment and performance.
Make better decisions under pressure.
Influence individuals across the organization.
Better understand how one’s leadership actions impact business results

Design Highlights

Program agenda.

As a result of the COVID-19 pandemic and the need for social distancing, this program was delivered virtually. However, this didn't preclude the need to give leaders an opportunity to connect with, and learn from, one another. In response to those needs, Insight Experience developed a fully remote, yet highly interactive, offering delivered over four half-day sessions.

Interactive Virtual Learning Format

Effective Decision-Making was designed to promote both individual and group activities and reflection. Participants access the program via a video-conferencing platform that allows them to work together both in large and small groups. Learning content and group discussions are done as one large group, enabling consistency in learning and opportunities to hear from all participants. The business simulation decision-making and reflection activities are conducted in small groups, allowing teams to develop deeper connections and conversations.

Simulation Overview

Participants assume the role of a General Manager for InfoMaster, a message management provider. Their leadership challenge as the GM is to translate the broader IIC organizational goals into strategy for their business, support that strategy though the development of organizational capabilities and product offerings, manage multiple divisions and stakeholders, and consider their contribution and responsibility to the broader organization of which they are a part.

Success in the simulation is based on how well teams:

Understand and translate organizational strategy into goals and plans for their business unit.
Align organizational initiatives and product development with broader strategies.
Develop employee capabilities required to execute strategic goals.
Hold stakeholders accountable to commitments and results.
Communicate with stakeholders and involve others in plans and decision-making.
Develop their network and their influence within IIC to help support initiatives for the organization

History and Results

Effective Decision-Making was developed in 2020 as an experience for senior-level leaders. After a successful pilot, the program was then rolled out to two more cohorts in 2021 and 2022. The senior-level leaders who participated in the program then requested we offer the same program to their direct reports. After some small adjustments to make the program more appropriate for director-level leaders, the program was launched in 2022 for approximately 100 directors.

Here is what some participants have said about this program:

“ One of the better programs we've done here at [our organization]. Pace was very quick but content was excellent and approach made it fun .”
“ Loved the content and the flow. Very nicely organized and managed. Thank you! ”
“ Really enjoyed the collaborative nature of the simulation.”
“ It was wonderful and I felt it is a great opportunity. Learnt and reinforced leadership training and what it would take to be successful.”
“One of the best I've experienced — especially appreciated how the reality of [our organization] was incorporated and it was with similarly situated peers.”
“This program was great! It gave good insight into how to enhance my skills as leader by adopting the leadership mindset.”
“Loved the fast pace, having a sim group that had various backgrounds in the company and seeing the results of our decisions at the corporate level.”
“Great program — I love the concepts highlighted during these sessions.”